Mythbusters: let’s bust myths about homelessness in our cities

Poverty in our cities is cruel. Jagrup Brar, MLA (member of Parliament) for Surrey,

Jagrup Brar enters the ‘Single Room Occupancy’ hotel that will be his home for a month.

volunteered to live on the lowest welfare rate: $610 a month. Brar’s experience displays the suffering of thousands in our wealthy cities. Brar lived in downtown Vancouver, first in illegal housing and then in a residence for single men. $425 was the cheapest accommodation available leaving him with less than $200 to live on for the month. After two weeks Brar had $25 left. He became dependent on free meals. He lost weight. Brar’s office said that texts from his cell phone became less coherent as the month progressed.

Catch-22s abounded. Brar blogged on the frustration of having to pay $4 to travel on a bus to access free food or clothing. He wrote about legal restrictions on work. Money earned in part-time employment is deducted from welfare payments dollar for dollar. ‘Binning’, making some money from recyclables found in garbage bins, is a way to supplement welfare. However only those with permission to earn money (given for example to those with disabilities) can keep their earnings. These laws make return to work via part-time employment unrealistic and create a cycle of unemployment.

Brar blogged on the serious health issues his friends suffered and the inaccessibility of treatment for them. He spoke of the lack of hygiene in public housing referring to one building that offers 1 toilet for 120 residents.

He blogged: I am told that there are 5,000 people living in ‘Single Room Occupancy’ hotels in Vancouver. A majority of them have no cooking facilities. As a result, these individuals have to line up for free food, sometimes for two to three meals a day, spending over four hours in line ups.

In response to his blog a journalist wrote: ‘It is impossible to live on $610 per month without going to charities or resorting to survival tactics’. Brar is calling on B.C. to ‘raise the rates’.

Myths abound regarding homelessness. ‘They want to be there’. ‘They should get a job’. ‘They are all addicts, so don’t help them’. This is not Brar’s experience of the people he spend January with. It is essential that we seek real information about homelessness. Reading Jagrup’s blog is a good start. Take a look at Jagrup’s blog yourself.

Here are three suggestions: First, if vulnerable people are to be dignified then basic welfare rates in B.C. need to be raised. Wherever we live, at election time let’s pay attention to the domestic welfare policy of each party. Second, do we not have a personal responsibility towards homeless people in our suburbs? It is easy enough to offer to buy a person ‘on the street’ a meal. In my experience homeless people almost always desire a meal, when offered. Third, Christian communities must find creative and personal ways to offer Christ’s radical hospitality. Jesus said, ‘give to the one who asks’ (Matt 5:42).

About Mark Glanville

Mark Glanville, a pastor-scholar, ministers at Grandview Calvary Church, Vancouver and is on the faculty of the Missional Training Center, Phoenix ( Mark studies towards a PhD in Old Testament at Trinity College, Bristol, U.K. (supervisors: Craig Bartholomew and Gordon Wenham). His research topic is the ‘ger’ (refugee) in Deuteronomy. Mark lives in Vancouver and speaks regularly at conferences on justice, mission and the Old Testament (e.g. Pastorum Live, Chicago, Apr 2013 and Missional Hermeneutics Conference, Grand Rapids, Nov 2013). Mark is theologically reformed and is ordained in the Presbyterian Church of Australia. Mark’s previous career was as a jazz pianist in Sydney and around Australia (Chick Corea and Wynton Kelly are his musical heroes). Mark spends his spare time mulling over ideas in coffee shops with Erin his wife and bushwalking with Mahla and Lewin their children. Mark is Aussie; he can break a crocodile's neck with two fingers. Mark blogs at
This entry was posted in justice, mission of the local church, politics and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Mythbusters: let’s bust myths about homelessness in our cities

  1. Terry says:

    Hi Mark:
    Sorry, he’s a politician, he has an agenda, and it’s most likely to make the party in power look bad while telling himself that he’s doing it for the homeless…. and he gets some free publicity for his next run at re-election….

  2. Pingback: The Ten Commandments – God’s Economics | …for he has made you beautiful

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s